Newcastle v Exeter, 06/02/2011


By Leipziger
February 4 2011

The weekend has got off to a good start with the news that James Hudson and Grant Shiells amongst others have signed new contracts, and hopefully it will continue on Sunday as we meet Exeter in the fourth leg of our five-game series against the Chiefs this season.

The LV= Cup group stage is coming to an end, and for the first time since 2007/08 we are in with a chance of qualifying for the semi-finals on the last matchday.  With a two-point advantage over Wasps, we have the advantage of knowing a win will definitely see us go through, while Exeter need a win to go through but must also rely on Cardiff beating Harlequins at the Stoop, presumably unlikely.

 

Wins for Harlequins and Ospreys, who play Wasps at the Liberty Stadium, will put us into the last four whatever the result at KP.  Both of these games are on Sunday too, although Harlequins v Cardiff kicks off at the slightly later time of 3.15pm.

 

Last weekend Exeter hammered Leicester 35-10 at Sandy Park, with five tries.  Leicester may not have been anywhere near full-strength, but that won’t have mattered to the Chiefs or the 7,000+ watching.  If we get 7,000 in on Sunday then I will, well, I’ll be very surprised.

 

Exeter have not won away from home since 30th October, when they beat Saracens at Vicarage Road.  Following that was a 23-23 at the Cardiff City Stadium in the LV= Cup, but since then they have lost four consecutive away matches, including against us at Netherdale in Europe before Christmas.

 

So Exeter lead our 2010/11 series 2-1 at the moment, having beaten us twice in Devon before Christmas ahead of our tight triumph in Netherdale, although overall it is 2-2 if we include our visitors’ only previous trip to Kingston Park, in the old (and better) knockout cup in 1998.  So unless it’s a draw this Sunday, which could well be enough to secure a semi-final place for us, one team will take the lead.

 

Hudson celebrates his new contract on Sunday by having Andrew van der Heijden start alongside him for the first time, Tim Swinson moving to the back row.  Jeremy Manning is back in the starting team, and James Fitzpatrick and James Hall get an opportunity to continue recent good form.

 

15 Jeremy Manning

14 Luke Fielden

13 Tane Tu'ipulotu

12 James Fitzpatrick

11 Alex Tait

10 Jimmy Gopperth

9 Micky Young

1 Jon Golding

2 Matt Thompson

3 James Hall

4 James Hudson (capt)

5 Andrew Van der Heijden

6 Tim Swinson

7 Will Welch

8 Ally Hogg

 

16 Rob Vickers

17 Kieran Brookes

18 Grant Shiells

19 Glen Townson

20 Mark Wilson

21 Hall Charlton

22 Luke Eves

23 Gcobani Bobo

 


Exeter team:

 

15 Paul McKenzie

14 Nemani Nadolo

13 Nic Sestaret

12 Bryan Rennie

11 Andrew Higgins

10 Gareth Steenson (capt)

9 Junior Poluleuligaga

1 Brett Sturgess

2 Chris Whitehead

3 Chris Budgen

4 Chad Slade

5 Dave Gannon

6 Dave Ewers

7 Andy Miller

8 James Phillips

 

16 Jon Vickers

17 Ruaidhri Murphy

18 Ignacio Elosu

19 Eoghan Grace


20 Herbie Stupple

21 Garrick Cowley

22 Ignacio Mieres

23 Josh Matavesi


Bookmark or share this story with:

Newcastle v Exeter, 06/02/2011
Discussion started by FalconsRugby.org.uk , 04/02/2011 12:50
FalconsRugby.org.uk
04/02/2011 12:50
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

alas
04/02/2011 12:54
Good to see Hall Charlton is fit again. Particularly when conditions are bad I would prefer to see him at 9 rather than erratic Micky.

Maccafan2
04/02/2011 13:26
Tait on the wing? Have I missed something!

steve1888
04/02/2011 13:30
Amesbury & M Tait are injured

DGNTR
04/02/2011 14:24
Decent enough bench for a change.

tightgit1
04/02/2011 23:31
Another negative tilt to a DG post

lizard118
05/02/2011 00:52
Happy with that though would've swapped Vickers for Thompson in the forwards. Not much choice to pick from in the backs.
Looking forward to seeing how James Hall performs against what is always a formidable Exeter front row.I was very impressed by his ten minute cameo against Flatman at Bath. Big future he has as a scrummaging prop I think.

DGNTR
05/02/2011 23:34
"Another negative tilt to a DG post"

Personal comments deleted



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011:02:07:09:15:32 by TouchLine.

lizard118
06/02/2011 17:54
Well done to the boys for doing-over Exeter today, especially after all the noise Baxter has been making about revenge. Was anyone here at the match? How did the forwards perform against a big Exeter pack and who were the stand out performers? Not much detail in the report on the offy and was asleep after a night shift so unable here commentary, so any details will be appreciated.

Hope injury to Fielden is not long term with the way he has been playing.

TouchLine
06/02/2011 17:56
Away Sf v Quins next

Maccafan2
06/02/2011 18:21
Great result,and a cracking final 10.Tait just needs to get them to play for the first 70. The pack performed well,and the backs produced the goods at the end.If M Young is moving on,and it appears he is,I'm afraid its overdue.His general play was poor,and his passsing abysmal.We certainly need a quality scrummie,as Charlton and Pilgrim are not enough.Quick word about twinkle toes ref Chris White.Did you leave your yellow in the west country?

newfalcon
06/02/2011 18:25
I thought we dominated the match but simply couldnt get over the line for a long time. What was encouraging was the number of offloads we saw, havent seen so many in a long time and they are crucial in developing an attack. Thought our scrum was good and Hall should start next week. VDH looked good, and I thought Charlton was good when he came on. Agree with Macca that Young was poor, he really didnt help Jimmy out at all. Disapointed to see Fielden leave the field he was playing well. All in all a good afternoon that should hopefully give much needed confidence to the team.

pityacker
06/02/2011 18:35
Forward pack a big improvement especially at lineout time where they took a number of Exeter throws.The scrum was pretty solid and for once was not getting wheeled backwards at a rate of knots.At times we didnt quite have the intensity of Exeter at the breakdown but happy with the improvements.Service to the backline from the base was very slow giving the backs very little space.On the few occassions we got quick ball and didnt kick it away a few nice moves were made.A long way to go but some definite improvements.After watching Scotlands recent internationals it is simply mind boggling that they continue to overlook the terrific Ally Hogg who once again stood out like a beacon.

alas
06/02/2011 18:35
Young gave a perfect imitation of a selfish, headless chicken. I doubt Leicester want him playing like that, but they're welcome to him. Charlton kicked the ball too much for my taste, but at least when he did pass the ball went at the right height and in the right direction.Hope the team gains confidence from the last 10 minutes and the win. Exeter have more players to come in for the vital league game, but looked very beatable providing the Falcons play well and don't give away unnecessary penalties.

Running Rugby
06/02/2011 18:39
What was the attendance today?

newfalcon
06/02/2011 18:49
Under 4,000. Felt like more than we have had for along time though with all the kids in attendance

clalan
06/02/2011 20:03
Well you may see three of the chief team next time in the league.
Looking forward to it.
Go and win the thing now.

lizard118
06/02/2011 20:10
Thanks for the insight guys. Glad James Hall played well. He didnt look fazed at all at playing Flatman at Bath last time out and actually gave him a big shove to boot. He does seem to have very good technique at scrum time, which is needed against clubs like Exeter. Onwards and upwards I hope from now.

sour
06/02/2011 21:08
One thing charlton did do is he got the forwards picking ball up when it was there - he didn't have to touch it before it was moved.

Don't understand why we wait until the last 5/10 minutes to pick up the tempo

tightgit1
07/02/2011 00:44
Personal comments deleted

Pleased to see the Falcons set piece do well especially in those conditions. Well done to those involved as it must of been very tough.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011:02:07:09:16:25 by TouchLine.

DGNTR
07/02/2011 00:57
(Sm103)

Sticks and stones......

nursepete
07/02/2011 08:35
Grow up lads, this is a rugby forum not a junior school playground.

On the pitch, again I thought James Hall did well as did all of the pack, we lacked that final pass to finally break them down. VDH and Hudson played well as did Hogg. Man of the match for me was Manning as he looked solid, always looked to run the ball and attack and encourages others around him.

Almostan Oldgit
07/02/2011 10:42
Other than the tries, the moment of the match was Manning teasing their tight head by holding out the ball for him whilst running away just out of reach - brightened up a dull first 70 mins.

Actually dull is a tad unfair, it was poor conditions and we did everything but score for the majority of the first half. Agree with comments about Young and Tulip. Very pleasing to see us play with a bit of vigour and adventure towards the end. Most pleasing were the players celebrations on scoring and the obvious "team" delight.

Happy Hooker
07/02/2011 14:52
Agree with much of the above. Our forwards fronted up really well against a massive Exeter pack and we more than held our own.Line-out good too and we nicked a few of theirs.

What disappointed me about the first half especially was that we failed to turn our dominance into points. There seemed to be a lack of communication between the No 8, the SH and the FH.

For instance there was one occasion when we were camped on the Exeter line for fully two minutes repeatedly trying to burrow our way over before losing the ball. And yet they had just one man defending the try-line left off the posts whereas we had four backs ready to attack. Why on earth didn't we throw the ball wide? Someone - usually the SH or the FH - has to call the shots in those situations. There was no direction at all.

Agree about Micky Young. He was poor and his passing was all over the place - round the head one minute down at the feet the next. By contrast when Hall Charlton came on the passes were going straight into the bread basket. Frankly I wouldn't play Young in this form, rather Charlton or Pilgrim if fit.

Gopperth had a poorish game too I thought. Always seemed to be caught in two minds although I don't think the slow service from Young helped. However he redeemed himself in the last ten minutes with some fine kicking.

Manning once again gave a flawless performance. He really is a superb little footballer - quick, creative, always looking for an opening.

When I complimented him after the game he said modestly: "Oh, I didn't have much to do!"

I like this guy.

DGNTR
07/02/2011 21:46
Agree with everything you have said there Hooky.

Though I've not met Manning, I agree that he is turning out to be a very decent player.

Maccafan2
07/02/2011 21:56
The guy is class,and the club are to be applauded for tying him up for 2 more years. Something decent from Munster,unlike the prop.Whatever happened to him?

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net