Friday night’s alright – if you don’t mind a fright


By Gelbel
October 29 2016

Under Headingley Carnegie’s lights, Yorkshire Carnegie carved out a win against a determined Jersey Reds side but not without a few howlers and spooky moments along the way.

First of all apologies for not providing my usual warts and all account – we realised we had no reviewer after the match kicked off. No apologies for my Halloween puns!

Jersey were up for this match and battled for every minute, taking the lead with an early try by slicing through the defence like a hot knife through butter. Within minutes, from a different style of kick-off, our backs moved the ball from side to side and Forsyth went over to open Yorkshire Carnegie’s account. Ford added the difficult conversion. 7-5.

Jersey hit back with a successful penalty before Stegman ended an exciting run of play by scoring an unconverted try. 12-8.

The dark arts of the scrum were starting to play their part and Yorkshire Carnegie were awarded a penalty for some goriness by Jersey and kicked to the corner. From the resulting play, Stedman broke free and charged over the line. With the try converted and a simple, successful penalty it was 22-8 as Boyce took an early break after all the props had a talking too and a finger waving at from Sir for their creepy scrummaging. Jersey took advantage of the extra man (to be honest more than one man – they are a massive side) and scored a quick try that was converted. 22-15 at half time.

Yorkshire Carnegie were awarded a penalty that Ford opted to kick to extend their lead. There was a long spell of pressure from Jersey which found the home side’s defence difficult to breach - not without some collateral damage as Schofield went off with a damaged shoulder and O’Donnell (the crowd were screaming for the league’s top try scorer to add to his account) was attended to a few times. Eventually Jersey scored and converted.

Yorkshire Carnegie had a chance to take a bigger lead but suffered the first of two howlers of losing possession from kicks to the corner after being awarded penalties. Cusack thundered onto the pitch and immediately got stuck in the play that led to Forsyth scoring his second, and Yorkshire Carnegie’s fourth, try of the night. Ford missed the conversion. 30-22.

Yorkshire Carnegie stepped up a gear and had plenty of attacking opportunities that mostly ended with mishandlings, Jersey upsetting the play or some strange decision making from the ref. Eventually, it all paid off with Ford ending an long spell of the backs looking for a gap in the Jersey defence. He missed the conversion.

Jersey would not give up, scoring a converted try from some good forward work. 35-29 and I was getting a bit spooked about whether we could hold on or not.

Something magical happened – the North Stand started chanting “Yorkshire, Yorkshire.” It came round to the Dark Side like a Mexican wave of sound. It put shivers up and down my spine and you could see it motivated the players. Heads up, shoulders back they put in more effort and got a penalty then a second following the line out. There was only seconds left so Ford kicked for the points – and missed.

A few observations

  • Overall it was a thrilling game with some very fast ball handling across all fifteen Yorkshire Carnegie players.
  • It’s sort of exciting to see our defence but it’s a bit harum-scarum and is not as solid as we’ve seen before.
  • When we will sort out the one score for us, one score for you attitude?
  • The one ‘mix it up kick off’ worked wonders – why don’t we see more of this?
  • Ford kept doing grubber kicks that didn’t work and refused to change tactic.
  • Buzz at 6 and Stedman at #8 is a good combination. It takes the pressure off Buzz who can then play much more subtly and sublimely while Stedman does the crash, bang, wallop stuff.

My cauldron of witch’s brew goes to Andy Forsyth for his two tries, lovely ball handling and a decent tackle or two.

I am off to find my inner (London) Scottish to hope they have a home win tomorrow so Yorkshire Carnegie can go to Reading top of the table.

Bookmark or share this story with:

Friday night’s alright – if you don’t mind a fright
Discussion started by TykesRugby.co.uk (IP Logged), 29/10/2016 09:37
TykesRugby.co.uk
TykesRugby.co.uk
29/10/2016 09:37
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2016:11:16:07:36:55 by Wildwillie .

John R
John R
29/10/2016 11:37
We almost managed to achieve "defeat out of victory" but stayed in front to the end.

A very entertaining match with much good back play from both sides, the points made by Gelbel (good report Gel!) are very valid and really need to be worked on big time.
We are giving too much away, despite our 7-0 winning in the league.

A sterner task next weekend chaps, now is the time to tighten up on the obvious deficiencies.

Up the Yorkshire Carnegie TYKES !

MESSAGES->author
leemingtyke
29/10/2016 22:52
Quote:
Gelbel
Something magical happened – the North Stand started chanting “Yorkshire, Yorkshire.” It came round to the Dark Side like a Mexican wave of sound. It put shivers up and down my spine and you could see it motivated the players. Heads up, shoulders back they put in more effort and got a penalty then a second following the line out.

^this

You could genuinely see the difference it made to the players. Long may it continue.

MESSAGES->author
opuscoitus
30/10/2016 01:25
Heard the chants on the radio good to hear and commentators mentioning the fans support. Long may it continue

MESSAGES->author
farmertyke
30/10/2016 11:11
Thank you Gelbel . Interesting your views on Buzz. Our little group are rather in the other camp. We think Buzz's wings have been clipped and that the new number 8 does not carry the ball as well.
One thing is clear though . We have conceded about double the points that London Irish have and unless we can address the defence we are always going to be second best.
As mentioned the crowd was v vocal , possibly due to the cheap student tickets . Whatever it was it produced a good atmosphere.

MESSAGES->author
farmertyke
30/10/2016 11:15
And another thing . Am I the only one that thought Mr Cussack looked as mobile as a block of concrete . I thought he would have made the wonderful Juan Gomez look speedy.

MESSAGES->author
corporalcarrot
30/10/2016 13:52
Quote:
farmertyke
As mentioned the crowd was v vocal , possibly due to the cheap student tickets . Whatever it was it produced a good atmosphere.

As an away supporter I fully agree with this and compared with the last time I was at Headingley for the B&I semi final it was like chalk and cheese. Friday night there was a real buzz in the crowd and I have no doubt the home crowd lifted YC in that last 10 minutes when Jersey were pressing forward and looking for the win. The home crowd on Friday really were the 16th man. I watched from the South stand with a tiny group of Jersey supporters and thoroughly enjoyed everything except the final score but have no real complaints as YC were the strongest team over the full 80. What happened to the lad who used to bring the big drum along - he was missed and always added to the atmosphere. All the best for the rest of the season lads except for the match at St Peter next Spring.

Don't kick it pick it up and GO FORWARD

MESSAGES->author
JDH
30/10/2016 16:09
I am in the buzz better at 8 camp too. His strengths match better in that position. He is a match winner at 8 V anyone.

haxbytyke
Haxbytyke
30/10/2016 16:41
Buzz at 8. Best player plays in each position.

COME ON LEEDS.
We've been through it all together.

MESSAGES->author
JDH
30/10/2016 18:31
Agreed. Think we are trying to fit players in.

ellishicks
ellishicks
30/10/2016 20:09
Great review Gel.
Interesting that you back Stedman for 8. I miss Buzz at 8. Brush was full of praise post-match for Oli. I suspect that he returned to us with some sort of promise of having a fair chance to stake his claim at 8. But he looks more like a 6 to me - gives us a sort of Morgan or Vunipola choice at 8. Both are needed in the team especially against Irish. Stedman has the extra experience but both are crucial leaders.

haxbytyke
Haxbytyke
30/10/2016 20:55
Thanks for the review Gel. I missed the game, but I thought we'd win easier than that. Didn't somebody somewhere predict a cricket score? Maybe it should have been, and this is a big concern. We do not put weaker teams away.

COME ON LEEDS.
We've been through it all together.

bird lover
bird lover
31/10/2016 08:39
Jersey are a shadow of last year and have loads of injuries but win is a win. Ealing are third Never !!!.the acid test Sat this will tell us how good we are against Prem standard team. We need a test to tell us just how good we are for it seems the Championship is not a patch on last year.Never good to have a two team league!!!

Selby Kev
Selby Kev
01/11/2016 20:09
Good review Gel.We can't afford to take the same approach next week. Every opportunity needs to be patiently put away with a 15 man defence when needed.Of course the best defence is scoring tries and piling on the pressure...but the gaps may be a wee bit harder to find.Huge forwards game....if they dominate and Stevie plays a blinder we are in with a chance. May need ALL of JF's kicks...keep practicing!

Anyway...whats all the fuss. We beat 'em away last time!..27-19.

(6-03-2011). Be happy with the same score eh?

Sorry, you do not have permission to post/reply in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net