What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

[url=http://[www.independent.co.uk]?]liked this preview of the game, its from the independant[/url]

Tough game. Probably be a lot of goals, hopefully the majority will be for us.

C'mon Newcastle

If play like we did against west bron then we will win NFP.

Loadsa of goals, they have been shocking lately - but have a point to prove

I really hoped Bellamy wouldn't be playing.

Yes same, I thought he was injured

Once again with shirt-pulling: penalty or not?

Never a foul on Perch.

Really pathetic dive from Carroll. Now 50K ain't wrong not to let him forget about it...

Fast start - Carroll could'av have scored if he hadn't have dived



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012:04:01:13:45:12 by Carys.

We look nervous.

Shelvey joins Carroll in the book.

Replays show Simmo with another goalline clearance from that corner...this one of a questionable nature...

Linesman on far side of pitch has been poor. Can't be getting throws wrong at this level.

1-0 CISSEEEEEE

HBA to Papiss!!!!

Cisse

Now it's their turn to be nervous. They've managed 1.2 goals/match this season.

Our LB has a tough job with Bellamy's pace. I hope he can't play the whole match.

Not sure how it's a foul to have a guy run into you.

Very strange officiating today.

Agreed

Actually, the match in general seems to have a strange atmosphere. Neither side seems settled.

Crowd response to our former players has been disappointing.

Agreed! I wish the crowd would stop booing our former players. That's only going to make them more determined to beat us, surely.

Exactly, Annie. I don't think it really intimidates anyone.

It's not like these guys have slagged the club either, statements about administrators aside.

Reina was fully beaten there.

Bellamy's the danger man. He has the beating of Jonas and Perch in him. I really, really hope he tires...

It drives me nuts that teams don't have a player further back when a corner is played, so that when the ball goes through the players in the box, it can be played straight back in.
Nuts!!!

Carroll, with the lack of support from his own fans will probably be bereft of confidence. I don't know if he's mentally strong enough to be fuelled by the criticism at the moment.

Bellamy however, revels in it. He's who worries me at the moment.

Enrique I don't understand the boos - he gave us good service during his time here and bar the contract debacle, didn't leave under a cloud particularly.

We need to get the ball to Ba. Flanagan can't handle him and the kid's already in the book.

The crowd are booing our former players because they left us for "better things!"
They deserve to be booed.
They didn't have the optimism to stay with us and they left.
We boo them because it's funny how they have taken a step down!
Let this be a lesson to any player that is thinking about leaving, because they will miss the Newcastle revolution.
We're going in the right direction people!
Don't be surprised if we are challenging the top 4 in a couple of seasons because I won't.
Great first half, Ben Arfa needs to see more of the ball, he has finally grasped English football and he is proving to be one of the best play makers around.

As long as we keep the same grit and determination in the second half, I can see us scoring another goal and we will see this game off comfortably NFP.

COME ON THE TOON!

Carroll was pushed. Compile the facts and ask yourself which story is more believable.

JE was a simple case of he thought he was worth more than offered. Again, no enmity from me.

Personally, I think their missing out on our season is punishment enough for any lack of faith!

FFS, Williamson! Almost made up for a lot there...

Jonas down. Not good. Don't like the idea of Raylor tracking Bellamy.

Gutierrez down - hopefully he will be ok

You get the impression Cisse & Skrtel don't enjoy each other's company.

We would bring Santon on instead of Raylor.
But we need to get our act together this second half!

2-0 lovely job - CiSSE

It's that man again!

What a goal, a real team effort Cisse 2-0

Our front three have a real understanding: Ba's cross, HBA's run puts off the defenders, Cisse has the cool head to finish. Beauty.

Well offside though

Sh!!!!

James F00kin' Perch.

Sorry for the criticism, son!

Guthrie Off

Gosling On

Gosling for Guthrie. Former looked to have taken a knock.

I'm worried at this rate Ashley will think we don't need another CB!

Credit where it's due - Perch is certainly taking his chance in the first team well.

Seriously. Perch has looked very good. His pace looks useful in the center of defense. Have to say, this has been one of Williamson's best performances in a while too.

Ha ha-Bellamy needed a few more inches there!

Quote:

tunyc
Our front three have a real understanding: Ba's cross, HBA's run puts off the defenders, Cisse has the cool head to finish. Beauty.

Best front three in the premiership in my opinion.
We've only done it for two games, but by god, doesn't it work a treat!

Quote:

Note To Self
I'm worried at this rate Ashley will think we don't need another CB!
Credit where it's due - Perch is certainly taking his chance in the first team well.

Couldn't agree more mate.
Williamson has had a good game as well.
Perch might keep coll out of the side at this rate.

Ameobi On

Cisse Off

C'mon Wor Shola

Agreed. Best combination of quality and form right now.

Cisse off for Shola. Kinda surprising. Change in formation?

FFS, let him get his hat trick!

He's on a yellow and has been jawing with Skrtel all game. Good call, I think. It would be beyond stupid for him to get sent off.

Ridiculous dribble from Mr. T!

Cisse hasn't played more than 78 mins for us. Still getting used to the pace of the Premiership.

Still need to pass occasionally, Hatem!

Andy Carroll off Kuyt on

Good stat, Annie.

Carroll off for Kuyt. Should have cheered him. Oh well.

Bellamy off for Henderson. That's a relief to me.

Not sure how Skrtel isn't in the book for persistent fouling.

handbags with the result: yellow for Perch, red for Reina...

lol!!!!

Reina Off liverpool no subs left

Yeah! I agree he was the dangerman.

Liverpool goalie off

I actually like Reina, but that ball was there to win, he bobbled it. You can't even act like you're gonna headbutt a guy.

Unnecessary. This really hasn't been a nasty game.

Enrique in goal

Enrique between the sticks!

FFS Get the ball forward

Totally unnecessary free kick for Liverpool.

Get the ball forward grrr!

Did I dream it or did they just say Mike Williamson was Man of the Match?

Strange game. Feels like the other shoe has dropped. LFC in serious trouble. If Sunlun had held on yesterday and Swansea manages a win today they'd be out of the top 10. Gotta spend wisely, I guess...and not make emotionally-pleasing but otherwise questionable appointments.

Advice from a club that's been there.

If not for the attacking display, my MOM is Perch...but everything considered, Cisse & HBA split it.

Thats a great 3 points for us. 11 points clear of 7th

Good win. 11 points ahead of Liverpool. I can hardly believe it.

Not that surprised, though. As I argued recently elsewhere, our squad is at least as good as theirs and generally younger. They have one serious goal threat and I can't see Gerrard getting back to where he was.

Now we need to finish the job-a big ask without Colo. Getting 64 points is totally doable though and we could top that-I'm assuming draws w/Swansea & EFC and nothing from CFC or City.

I was right Mike Williamson was made Man of the Match. Who'd have thunk it.

Seriously. Also, second week in a row of post-match interviews...apparently he's the new beautiful face of NUFC!

What do you think, ladies?

I find him a bit wimpy, though he did play well today defending and unlucky twice not to score

Hand-wringing over Simmo's clearance, which definitely was handball, is bothering me. Five minutes before that, HBA had his shirt blatantly pulled by Enrique in the box. That's more of a discussion for me. The Simpson thing happened quickly and the linesman didn't see it. Done and done. It happens. On the other hand, week in-week out we see instances of shirt pulling in the box. Sometimes it's a penalty, sometimes it isn't. Clarification, please?

My wife says he's no Haris Vuckic, her newest favorite in our squad.

I told her she'd be robbing the cradle.

My sister is mad for Cabaye ... I've a man crush on Cisse right now

Upon review of the replay, I think Carroll may have scuffed his attempt to hop over Krul and honestly tripped himself.

I can't help defending him. He's a Geordie boy after all.

I'm right there with you. Rodney (still think he should have gotten that on his shirt), you're my hero!

Great stuff, we're hitting form at just the right time.


Get regular updates from one of TyneTalk's mintest posters, follow: [www.twitter.com] @adameverett92

Class result and Im over the moon. I felt a little for Carroll TBH but you cant have your cake and eat it. You cant leave for 80k a week and not expect a bit booing. I was there and he looked like he dived again in the second half, clutching his knee.

In my eyes, Jose deserved more grief at the way he went on during the end of his career here. Neither wanted the ball at all and were terrible today.

Perch was my MOTM and Williamson was class. Cisse, christ he can finish. How did he get that header in and was cool for the second. Is that 7 in 7. Amazing. Big praise for BA though. He might not have scored as many but he works his socks off and allows so much room for Cisse and HBA.

10 points clear of 7th, 11 from Pool and 12 from the Mackems. Its great.

Dont worry about us not getting a CB due to Perch's form. Hat off to the lad, but we will still get a CB and LB. If we manage Europe, we will need the squad.

WRT enrique and carroll, they are reaping the fruitage of their lack of faith in the club, and it is ironic that they have effectively taken a step down albeit for higher pay.

I still don't see the point of booing them whenever they get on the ball.
Bellamy maybe deserves it but the other 2 don't, they made way for better players and their leaving the club helped us to move forward.
One of the commentators summed up carrolls sale rather concisely I think when he said something like 'its a classic case of a club selling a good player in order to get a better player'

WRT the game, the performance was solid.

Perch was immense all over the park and he's my MOM with Cisse a very close second. It seems I really will have to change my opinion of him, although I still feel sick when I see his name on the starting line-up.
My only criticism of Cisse is that his first goal was arguably his most difficult chance to score.
He gets into so many good positions and I felt he could have had a hatrick or better in both of his last two matches.

Williamson had a pretty good game and while I'm not a fan of his I have to give him credit for that.
Still, it seems he must have at least one moment of complete madness in a game and yesterday was no exception.
He needs to cut that out because a better liverpool could have turned his stupid mistakes into a goal and built on that.
The problem is that we always look solid before we concede. letting a team back into the game at 2-1 would effectively hand them a draw or better, since once we concede its backs to the wall invariably and we cant seem to get back on track.

I've felt on a few occasions this season we've gotten very lucky not to concede in the dying minutes of a game, apart from at Arsenal, and lets not kid ourselves they probably should have scored much earlier.

That goal he gave west brom last time out was ridiculous, incredibly retarded defending.
If morrison hadn't been injured with about 15min to go - knocking them down to 10 men since they'd already made all their subs - they might have got back into that game as WBA are wont to do against us. FFS



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012:04:02:11:24:37 by piston26.

I've said it many times that i only wanted to see Perchinio playing in the midfield but his performances have been good over the last 2 games but lets home this wasn't a one off and they can form a decent partnership during Colo's abscence!

Plenty of controversy throughout the match but we outplayed them and outclassed them,i never thought i'd watch a Liverpool match and forget that their messiah was playing!

Again HBA was fantastic along with the 2 Demba's and it was good management from AP to bring Cisse off seen as he already had been booked and the way him and Baldy were going at each other he could have easily got a second!

Again the management and players showed great control and maturity once Reina had been sent off, it would have been easy to get carried away and try to test JE in goal and leave massive gaps at the back that may have allowed liverpool back into the match!

I don't understand why Carroll was slated, except that I suppose most geordies at the match have swallowed the laughable narrative of his departure put forth by DL.

When all he had to do was say: "we were offered over 30M, we will always take that, end of story." Nope, couldn't pass on the chance to peddle some rhetoric.

I do enjoy pointing this out to my LFC-supporting coworker:

Andy Carroll = (2 X Papiss Cisse) + (5 X Hatem ben Arfa)