A Review Of The New Jimmy Adamson Biography By Tim Quelch


By Tim Quelch
September 7 2013

In a world dominated by sprawling, faceless organisations, how often are we inclined to yearn for the days of yore when it seemed as if warm, personal commercial operations, embodying family-like features, were more prevalent? And yet, as Dave Thomas's intriguing biography of Jimmy Adamson suggests, these family-like organisations of yester-year were not immune to internecine strife.

      Jimmy Adamson is not a household name, at least among those not yet of a 'certain age', and without any association with the former 'Cotton towns' of North East Lancashire, or with Sunderland AFC immediately after Bob Stokoe's glorious Roker reign, or with Leeds United of the late 70s, still in mourning at Don Revie's departure. The late Jimmy Adamson was formerly a professional footballer with Burnley FC during the immediate Post-war years - a Rolls Royce defender whose poise, power and positional acumen drew copious plaudits from his fellow players and members of the press but, alas, no international recognition - at least in terms of full representative honours - during a career which spanned the late forties, the fifties and early sixties. He was rightly awarded Footballer of the Year in 1962, though. This was the year in which he captained his club side in a memorable FA Cup final against Spurs, having led them to the First Division title in 1960 - a remarkable triumph given that Burnley was then the smallest town or city to produce a Football League Championship-winning side, with that team assembled at lower cost than any of the First Division champions before it. Those distinctions still apply to this day if the history of the English Premiership is added to that of the Football League's premier competition.

      The strength of that Burnley side which punched so hard & successfully well above its weight lay not only in the outstanding individual and collective skills of its players but also in the club's visionary coaching; and its extensive scouting networks, enabling it to net the most promising young talent around; plus, crucially, in its 'all for one' and 'one for all' family mentality. Many of its young recruits, like Adamson, came from harsh, impoverished working-class backgrounds. This warm club not only honed their raw talent, it provided emotional sustenance also. This enfolding environment carried obligations as well as benefits, though, and, in time, Adamson became enmeshed in these, as his professional and personal ambitions, began to conflict with those he was answerable to, much to his detriment and that of the club.

      Although Jimmy Adamson failed to gain the international recognition his playing skills merited, his visionary coaching ability was not overlooked by the FA. For he became England manager, Walter Winterbottom's right-hand man at the Chile World Cup finals in 1962, quickly attracting the admiration of England's leading players, such as Bobby Charlton. In testament to the high esteem in which Sir Bobby held Adamson, he contributes a Foreword to this book. So impressive was Adamson's coaching skills that he was offered the post of England manager when Winterbottom retired immediately after returning from Chile. Adamson turned the job down, though, preferring to extend his playing career. So the job was offered to Alf Ramsey! As they say, 'the rest is.... '

      Adamson's unprecedented refusal was perhaps motivated by other factors. He seemed loathe to leave the emotional comfort of Burnley. His wife was not keen to move to London, either. Besides, Burnley's bluff, dictatorial chairman, Bob Lord, appeared to be offering him a coaching job for life at Turf Moor.

      Burnley's improbable success during the fifties and early sixties owed much to the strength of a triangular coalition between its leaders. At the club's helm was the autocratic but forward-thinking chairman, Bob Lord. While he ran the club, as he did his butcher's trade, with inexhaustible energy and fierce ambition, he had no intention of buying a dog and barking himself, at least while his meat business demanded so much of his time. He selected his managers wisely. Arguably, his best appointment was that of former club captain, Alan Brown. Brown's shrewd, ground-breaking coaching skills set Burnley well on their way to their title triumph in 1960. Brown was eventually succeeded by the avuncular, ever- enthusiastic and passionate Harry Potts, also a former star player at Turf Moor. Potts had the good sense to build upon Brown's legacy, and in this regard, he was indebted to the ingenuity of his boot room staff, namely Billy Dougal and Ray Bennion, and to that of his leading players, particularly Jimmy McIlroy and Jimmy Adamson, who forensically devised and rigorously rehearsed an extensive array of dead-ball ploys which so often wrong-footed Burnley's illustrious opponents, at home and abroad.

      Lord treated Potts and Adamson like surrogate sons - at least while they continued to deliver what he expected and, crucially, while they recognised his unchallengeable position as head of the Turf Moor family. Potts had been one of Lord's favourite Burnley players so he featured high in his regard when it came to choosing a permanent Burnley manager, in succession to Brown, in 1958. Moreover Potts seemed less disposed to confront Lord in the manner of his strong-minded predecessor, Alan Brown. Potts was a good son. He did as Bob Lord demanded including selling players he'd rather have kept. Moreover, he delivered the League title in 1960. So when Bob Lord acted quickly to secure Adamson a coaching post at Burnley to prevent him being nabbed by a bigger club, he thought his two 'sons' offered a dream ticket. Lord expected the two of them to work in harmony, as they had as manager and captain of the Championship-winning side, in restoring Burnley's glorious success, in the face of an increasingly harsh economic climate that forced Burnley to sell its talented youngsters in order to survive. However, soon after the 'dream team' was established it became clear very quickly that troubled waters lay ahead, for Adamson was a man of the future while Potts was one of the past. Adamson was an astute tactician, prepared to adjust selections and style of play according to the strength and game plans of the opposition; whereas Harry Potts relied upon his players to express themselves on the pitch with little instruction from him. He simply demanded that they play with 'a chuckle in their boots'. Adamson had seen in Chile that such home-spun philosophy was out of place in an increasingly competitive and defensively-inclined modern game. It wasn't long before Potts and Adamson were clashing over team selection, tactics, coaching and training drills.

      Eventually Bob Lord deposed Harry Potts, his first 'surrogate son', replacing him with his second, appointing Adamson as manager in Potts's place in 1970. Potts took his demotion with admirable graciousness but he was bereft at being separated from the job he loved so much and hurt that his loyalty should count for so little. But whereas Potts dutifully subscribed to his family obligations at Turf Moor, Adamson seemed less prepared to endure these despite complying with Bob Lord's insistence that he and his wife lunch with the Lords each Sunday. Ultimately the tensions between Adamson and Lord would lead to ruinous friction as the bottom line bit harder into the slender resources of a small town club beset by a declining local economy following the abdication of 'King Cotton'.

      When an organisation is faced with the need for critical changes in order to survive, a family culture can often get in the way. Too often those placed at risk by change feel they are entitled to set the agenda, falsely believing that their loyalty and emotional ties count for much more than is conceivably possible. In Dave Thomas's probing account, the perils of such a scenario are graphically and skilfully captured. Ironically, both Potts (supported by his feisty and protective wife) and Adamson felt that their established positions in the Turf Moor 'family' entitled them to more power and influence than was feasible given the club's dwindling resources of young talent and draining cash reserves.

      This is a very well-written book about crushed personal ambition, examining closely how one of our leading football coaches, with the world seemingly at his feet, fell from the sun. While this is essentially a football book it has resonance for other walks of life. From a footballing perspective, it offers a fascinating study of the privations endured by footballers over half a century ago, both in their early years and as young professionals. But above all it provides a fascinating perspective on the decline of footballing dynasties - not only at Bob Lord's Burnley but also at Leeds United in the wake of Don Revie's departure and Brian Clough's 'damned' stay.

Highly recommended

Jimmy Adamson: The Man Who Said No to England, Pitch Publishing 17.99

Bookmark or share this story with:

A Review Of The New Jimmy Adamson Biography By Tim Quelch
Discussion started by TheLongside.co.uk , 07/09/2013 14:34
TheLongside.co.uk
07/09/2013 14:34
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

foutrelebordel
07/09/2013 16:28
i'm confused. this is not a review of the book, but a precis of adamson's career.

in fact if you've read this review you probably don't need to read the book.

you need a better reviewer, dave.

Dave Thomas
07/09/2013 16:39
Well it does say recommended... so I should be pleased with that...

the kindle version is a bargain I have to say at just 3 quid something

Dave Thomas
07/09/2013 16:43
and it does say intriguing...

what it could have said is how fascinating the Leeds chapters are ... the libel case... the hell he went through... the real effort he made to sign Kevin Keegan from Hamburg...

Leeds fans should try to imagine the impact Keegan would have had on club and city

how it was his Leeds experiences that finally finished any last interest he had in the game...

foutrelebordel
07/09/2013 16:49
it takes him eight lengthy paras to mention you, dave. most people wouldn't get that far, i suspect.

you're right, it does say highly recommended. i'd have liked him to show us why though.

Dave Thomas
07/09/2013 17:50
fourtel... you're not as daft as I look

foutrelebordel
07/09/2013 18:23
read opening chapter on amazon. the bits on bob lord are interesting and rather revealing.

any plans for BL biog?

Dave Thomas
07/09/2013 18:46
somebody is working on one... but it may be a while yet

Dave Thomas
08/09/2013 15:48
currently number 1 in the Kindle English footie books... just beating Wayne Rooney by a forehead

bordeauxclaret
08/09/2013 21:29
Quote:
foutrelebordel
it takes him eight lengthy paras to mention you, dave. most people wouldn't get that far, i suspect.

If you're going to do a review of a review at least you could try and get your facts right, it mentions Dave in the second sentence.

BC
Prediction League Champion 2006/7
Fantasy League Winner 2007/8

soapylily
08/09/2013 23:41
DT more popular that Wayne Rooney - well done Dave!

Dave Thomas
09/09/2013 07:14
alas the positions are now changed... fame is fleeting... infamy is permanent

bordeauxclaret
09/09/2013 11:19
I'm buying it for my Kindle later today Dave, see if that gets you back up there.(Sm14)

Just curious, I'm assuming an author won't make as much from a Kindle sale, is there much of a difference ?

BC
Prediction League Champion 2006/7
Fantasy League Winner 2007/8

aggi
09/09/2013 12:26
I don't know about Dave in particular but generally the author gets a higher percentage of ebook receipts to reflect the fact that the publisher has had to do far less work in selling them.

Often on small print runs, as the costs are relatively high compared to a large print run, you get more on the ebook.

http://imagegen.last.fm/longside3/recenttracks/mauwf79.gif

ManHug
09/09/2013 13:28
Will be getting this for Xmas. Hopefully there will be a signing session around then?

http://www.songpeople.co.uk/images/stories/george-berry.jpg

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_6e-pXyJijUs/S6fVhRO6G4I/AAAAAAAAAQw/14YgqoQB1T4/s320/800px-Boney_M_Bobby_Farrell_2006.jpg

Dave Thomas
09/09/2013 19:23
MH
I'd be hoping the club shop will do a Christmas signing session... or a book evening...

but books are a low priority in the shop scheme of things because "they are only 1% of total sales" I was told

So I said but hang on market the bloody things and make it 2%
and
don't turn your nose up at 1% because its the little things at 1% that all add up to 10% eventually of total sales.

Aggi yes the royalties % is greater for kindle stuff but the Adamson Kindle price is only £3.83 and before you get the % all the admin costs are deducted etc... so lets say its 20% its hardly mouthwatering

and on hardback lets say the royalty is 10%... that's not 10% of £17.99 its 10% of the £9 the publisher sells it to the retailer at...

so if my maths is correct that 90p a book so even if it sells 1000 copies, £900 might head my way... on something I've taken 9 months to work on

but over the years I've averaged it out that it costs me £900 to write a book over that 9 month period

re the Carlisle book... he's probably had a nice fat advance... and I'll guess the ghostwriter will have been paid maybe five thousand to write it.

fred dibnah
09/09/2013 20:50
Quote:
Dave Thomas
and on hardback lets say the royalty is 10%... that's not 10% of £17.99 its 10% of the £9 the publisher sells it to the retailer at...
.

I dont feel as bad now for buying it off th'amazon website for £5 less.

bordeauxclaret
09/09/2013 22:01
As I've just paid £3.82 for it on my Kindle Dave then I'm right to think, despite the higher %, you're getting less than if I'd bought the book ?

BC
Prediction League Champion 2006/7
Fantasy League Winner 2007/8

Dave Thomas
09/09/2013 22:12
Yep BC... well less... all i can suggest is that on your annual trip to Waterstones Leeds at Christmas... you buy a book as well... I'll show you where they are...(Sm128)

bordeauxclaret
09/09/2013 22:18
There is one good point about my Kindle Dave, I can only put it on Mrs BC's Kindle for her to read it, whereas there could be 6 or more people I could lend a book to.

Maybe a Kindle sale will indirectly lead to more book sales.

BC
Prediction League Champion 2006/7
Fantasy League Winner 2007/8

aggi
09/09/2013 23:03
That's roughly what I was thinking Dave but I didn't realise the SRP was as high as £17.99.

All the publishers are still feeling their way a bit with ebook sales, particularly given the Apple skullduggery.

Some of the advances are I've seen over the years have been pretty amazing, makes me wish I was a bestselling author.

http://imagegen.last.fm/longside3/recenttracks/mauwf79.gif

Dave Thomas
10/09/2013 06:40
The Rooney advances were legendary and I understand haven't been recouped.

The best known was Pippa Middletons's for her turkey of a book.

But one bestselling book and thats yer pension sorted

Dave Thomas
10/09/2013 06:42
Adamson down to 3rd this morning
Rooney in second
Bradford at Wembley top

Longsiders1882
10/09/2013 10:20
Just bought it Dave - loved this customer review

Quote:
a good read but the author just seem to keep giving is opinion most of the time.was looking for a more in depth review

Will you just stop having an opinion

"A truth’s initial commotion is directly proportional to how deeply the lie was believed. It wasn’t the world being round that agitated people, but that the world wasn’t flat. When a well-packaged web of lies has been sold gradually to the masses over generations, the truth will seem utterly preposterous and its speaker a raving lunatic."

"The ideal tyranny is that which is ignorantly self-administered by its victims. The most perfect slaves are, therefore, those which blissfully and unawaredly enslave themselves."

Dave Thomas
10/09/2013 15:26
yes it was a bizarre review/comment... he said it was a good read... gave it 4 and a half stars... but had too many of my opinions...

I just told the story... and I can't think of more than half a dozen opinions I had... if that... let me know if you find any...

and good reviews always welcome... i do think they must make a difference on Amazon to people in two minds

ManHug
10/09/2013 18:57
Think what you do is fantastic Dave when you consider you only break even from it.

On top of breaking even have you lost all the hours too or do you factor the hours into your 'approx £900'?

Is it the love for it or that hope you may write 'the pension', as you put it, that drives you to pick up the quill?

http://www.songpeople.co.uk/images/stories/george-berry.jpg

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_6e-pXyJijUs/S6fVhRO6G4I/AAAAAAAAAQw/14YgqoQB1T4/s320/800px-Boney_M_Bobby_Farrell_2006.jpg

Dave Thomas
10/09/2013 19:26
Heck I've never counted the hours i spend... that's where it being just a retirement hobby comes in... lets say even at £10 ( I come cheap) an hour and 5 days a week I do 3 hours

£150 a week for lets say 30 weeks...

Longsiders1882
10/09/2013 19:41
£10 an hour? I've loads of odd jobs need doing Dave (Sm14)

"A truth’s initial commotion is directly proportional to how deeply the lie was believed. It wasn’t the world being round that agitated people, but that the world wasn’t flat. When a well-packaged web of lies has been sold gradually to the masses over generations, the truth will seem utterly preposterous and its speaker a raving lunatic."

"The ideal tyranny is that which is ignorantly self-administered by its victims. The most perfect slaves are, therefore, those which blissfully and unawaredly enslave themselves."

soapylily
10/09/2013 23:18
I've just ordered one on Amazon DT as well as the CC one out tomorrow, I'll try and ignore the language in it...

Dave Thomas
11/09/2013 07:44
Phone a friend Soapy... if everyone did that I could afford a new pair of shoes

ManHug
11/09/2013 10:29
'Underdog' arrived yesterday - absolute spanking condition and only £2.81 inc delivery.

http://www.songpeople.co.uk/images/stories/george-berry.jpg

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_6e-pXyJijUs/S6fVhRO6G4I/AAAAAAAAAQw/14YgqoQB1T4/s320/800px-Boney_M_Bobby_Farrell_2006.jpg

Dave Thomas
11/09/2013 14:20
It never really hit the charts or media attention MH... despite beibng a beautifully written book...

to my astonishment Adamson is still top of the Kindle English footie books... tell yer friends...

ManHug
12/09/2013 09:19
'Underdog' you referring to DT? I will be taking it to Spain at the back end of the month for poolside reading.

http://www.songpeople.co.uk/images/stories/george-berry.jpg

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_6e-pXyJijUs/S6fVhRO6G4I/AAAAAAAAAQw/14YgqoQB1T4/s320/800px-Boney_M_Bobby_Farrell_2006.jpg

Dave Thomas
12/09/2013 18:50
Yep the Adamson is still top of the 100 English footie books (Kindle) and the hardbackl is now at number 4...

amazing

Foreverclaret
14/09/2013 08:12
Adamson kindle now top and the book 2nd, great stuff. (Sm152)

LINK



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013:09:14:08:14:07 by Foreverclaret.

Dave Thomas
14/09/2013 09:26
And a win today... please God... how good would that be... top of another table... for a bit anyway

Mauritius Claret
18/09/2013 08:33
I wonder if mention is made of Jimmy Adamson who captained Burnley during their first visit to Mauritius in 1954 !

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net
 

StreamFootball - Burnley