Carroll - Had no chance with the shot - 6

G Neville - Rather quiet. - 7

Silvestre - Shaky...especially when under pressure. Lacked concentration- 5

Ferdinand - Could have done better on occasions. Otherwise, solid. - 7

Heinze - Alright performance - 6.5

Ronaldo - A bit too much dribbling...but has started passing more. And his decision making needs to improve - 5.5

Keane - Was great in the first half...but faded as the game progressed. -7

Scholes - Made great usage of the spaces in midfield. Getting back to his best.- 8

Giggs - Wasn't involved much in the last 30 mins; however, he always looked dangerous-7

Smith - Good goal, fought hard, but could have done a bit more. -7

Rooney - Messed up some decent chances; should have done better with the chances he had. -6

Should have introduced Fletcher, and maybe Bellion in the second half. 

A great first half, but a shame that there were too many missed chances. Frustrating second half; were just sitting back too much.