On a bright Saturday afternoon at Richmond, even before kick-off we were more aware than ever of the impact of a certain players transition to Yorkshire Carnegie when the team line up was announced:- “And at No 10, Sports Personality of the Year nominee, Kevin Sinfield!”
Scottish had a brief flourish before Kev added to his growing points tally for Carnegie with a penalty after 4 minutes. It was then the turn of the home team to gain the ascendency with a Lydon penalty and a converted try following a missed tackle some 30 metres out. It took a further fifteen minutes for Carnegie to reply following a quickly taken tap penalty by Buzz led to a try for a rampaging Lee Imiolek. After Carnegie’s first rolling maul of the match, on 37 minutes, led to a penalty and a team warning to Scottish for “collapsing the maul” referee Thomas deemed the second attempt merited a penalty try and the sin-binning of a Scottish prop. It was noticeable as half-time approached that Kevin Sinfield’s influence on the game was growing even allowing for a couple of minor mishaps.
At the start of the second half Scottish came back strongly and a kick to touch by Jonah with his foot over the 22 metre line gave Scottish possession which they utilised to fashion a try for Mark Bright. Another noticeable feature of the game was Harry Leonard’s role at centre which seems to becoming something of a complement to the work of Kevin at fly-half. After a missed London Scottish penalty Chris Jones replaced Dean Schofield and at the ensuing line-out another rolling maul was successful in giving Andy Saull a try on his return from a lengthy injury layoff. There was still time for a Scottish fight-back and the try which brought them level came after Carnegie were pulled back, after kicking the ball out, for carrying the ball back into their own 22. The referee got this right although he had missed Scottish getting away with the same offence earlier in the match! The match ended with Carnegie completing a forwards “full-house” and another push over try, this time for Charlie Beech. Although Kevin’s conversion attempt hit the post and stayed out Carnegie management of the last few minutes of injury time was sufficient to get them over the finishing line with a five pointer.
Following last week’s impressive win at Scarborough, today was always going to be a more difficult exercise with Scottish turning out a stronger team, but a good all round performance saw the boys move clear at the top of group 3, a position they will maintain irrespective of the result of the Ospreys v Munster match on Sunday.
………….. to Heathrow, en-route to Belfast for one Kevin Sinfield! GOOD LUCK!!
K.S did ok, he looks pretty good when the focus of attack is a narrow one but he does not possess a pass off either hand of sufficient quality to hit wider runners with a decent flat ball. That was still being done by Leonard after K.S just shipped the ball backwards to him. Consequently Carnegie's backs were often caught well behind the gain line. We had no pace or feet at 9, 10 and 12.
The Scottish backs looked more assured in possession and we again looked to lack any ceativity.
The pluses, the forwards were strong and played for the full 80 minutes showing some neat touches and impressively soft hands, Neilsen again had a good game as did Imiolek, he does look impressive in loose play.
A good confidence boosting win, but all is not well in the backs.
Too much too soon for Sinfield. Don't understand this policy of playing him all the time. He can't pass. This is a different game. He can't be a quality fly half this season.
Watching Kev at the London Welsh game, I thought he was very predictable with his passing. But he has come on in leaps and bounds since that "premature" introduction to the 10 shirt and I look forward to seeing him tomorrow.
A bold statement to say he can't pass given his track record in a game that has more passing than Union.
I call it as I see it. I have absolutely no problem with where KS comes from and I have zero agenda. I want him and the team to be successful. I do see huge gaps in his game which I do not believe he will have time to fix by the end of this season. Yes he can offload and provide well-timed pop passes. No he can't yet provide flat wide distribution at pace. Hence my "can't pass" comment. I also don't think he should be wheeled in to first team play when there are other 10s who are currently better. If it was anyone else they would be learning their craft at Wharfedale and coming into the team when they can genuinely compete for the shirt.
Errr... I may not entirely see eye to eye with Haxby about KS but I'm very happy to have a debate on here and respect everyone's views. We are hopefully all passionate enough to be opinionated and I hope the strength of the arguments presented are what's important. This is what the forum is for isn't it?
I am very Calm and support our team and want to get to Prem !!!! It's Cool. It was just the definition of Opinion ! We are 3 on 3 after the Welsh debacle long may it continue.
Sorry, you do not have permission to post/reply in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment.
We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals.
We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards.
If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing
abuse@sportnetwork.net