EWAN WHOSE ARMY. BATH v GLOUCESTER


Richards: convincing
IMAGO/PPAUK

By theredseat
November 10 2026

That was a pretty enjoyable start to the PREM Cup block was it not? Ewan Richards led his crew of mostly fringe first teamers, prospects and students down to Sandy Park and produced arguably the most convincing 80 minutes of rugby a Bath team has managed all season. The Cup rolls on with Gloucester coming down the M5 to visit The Rec this weekend with both teams holding one win and one defeat from their opening two fixtures. 

Bath continue to use the PREM Cup to mostly build experience for younger players and the expectation would be a broadly similar line up to be used again for this fixture. Unsurprisingly it was the younger players with more significant first team experience in the likes of Arthur Green and Ciaran Donoghue who particularly stood out in Exeter but with plenty of key PREM and Euro fixtures still to come it will be interesting to see if they are given a full block of Cup games to show what we know they can do or whether they are deployed more sparingly with future battles in mind. 

Most recent injury reports from Rory Murray’s desk suggest an imminent return to play for one or two first team squad members with Will Muir a possibility to occupy Horse Corner again on Saturday. The game may come too soon for Vilkesa Sela though who was previously targeting a late November come back. We may also see a pre-league tune up for Quinn Roux in the next fortnight now his hush hush training knock seems to be sorted. 

For the visitors who are now right in the thick of the playoff picture and with their own cohort of stars away on international duty it seems safe to assume they will send a similarly developmental line up. Some names to watch out for include the Knight brothers and Junior Denny who are exciting athletes in the back line and the quadruple barrelled forward combo of Freddie Ogden-Metherell and Kealan Freeman-Price. All have featured in England’s recent age group squads and should offer a good comparison for some of our own young prospects.

Bookmark or share this story with:

EWAN WHOSE ARMY. BATH v GLOUCESTER. TEAM UP!
Discussion started by Comeonmylovers.co.uk (IP Logged), 10/11/2026 08:21
Comeonmylovers.co.uk
Comeonmylovers.co.uk
10/11/2026 08:21
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2026:11:17:17:48:15 by CoochieCoo.

P G Tips
P G Tips
10/11/2026 08:24
Thanks trs

I think - and very much hope- that Bath will stick to recent script and deploy the "Purples" for these early rounds as much as possible.

Maybe we will go stronger in the knockout phases, depending in progress in other competitions?

PG

opti
Optimist
10/11/2026 09:24
I don't much mind who Bath field as long as the two teams are well-matched in terms of first-teamers/fringe players. A sold out Rec deserves a really good contest.

Bath Supporter Jack
Bath Supporter Jack
10/11/2026 10:46
100%

Bath Supporter Jack
Bath Supporter Jack
10/11/2026 11:58
I `would pick the same squad as for Exeter with of course room for a Muir return!

Great title!!

DorsetBoy
Dorset Boy
10/11/2026 12:33
JvG did say that most of the first team squad were on a 12 day break after the Sale game so it will be a similar set up this weekend to last I'd expect.

theredseat
theredseat
10/11/2026 13:20
Sam Winters on duty for the Uni side tomorrow night which would presumably rule him out of starting on Saturday. Given he played on the left wing last week that seems a reasonable indicator of seeing Muir back on the field for this one. Just call me the Horse Whisperer if so...

Mike the Taxi
Mike the Taxi
10/11/2026 14:07
Quote:
theredseat
Sam Winters on duty for the Uni side tomorrow night which would presumably rule him out of starting on Saturday. Given he played on the left wing last week that seems a reasonable indicator of seeing Muir back on the field for this one. Just call me the Horse Whisperer if so...

...or Hoarse Whisperer?

MESSAGES->author
shipwrecked
10/11/2026 17:50
Quote:
theredseat
Sam Winters on duty for the Uni side tomorrow night which would presumably rule him out of starting on Saturday. Given he played on the left wing last week that seems a reasonable indicator of seeing Muir back on the field for this one. Just call me the Horse Whisperer if so...

Perhaps, but equally it might mean the Jack Woods fills that spot as he is not in the uni 23.

https://i.ibb.co/YTDNDCdd/Tyler-Offiah-185.jpg

Tyler Offiah

Opinion is based on assumptions, whereas fact is based on observation or research.

Charlieboa1
Charlieboa1
11/11/2026 06:56
Will be an interesting selection.

Assume/ hope we will see a similar group over the next 2 fixtures but would be great to see the likes of sela, roux, DDP, muir come back in for a game if ready.

Largely <23 players supplemented by a few experienced guys is always the right blend for me in this comp.

You want to get through to get more games into our massive squad

gaz59
gaz59
11/11/2026 11:54
Really good review and great title

MESSAGES->author
exbathballboy
11/11/2026 19:50
Would love to see the same approach again, a mix of youth with first team fringe players getting minutes.

Also same approach with playing style, offloads, being more expansive and allowing players freedom to play, as this is a development tournament more than anything.

Bath Hammer
Bath Hammer
13/11/2026 00:01
We need to retain the progress we achieved against Exeter to have a chance against Gloucester. They beat us soundly recently & are deservedly above us in the table.

theredseat
theredseat
13/11/2026 12:04
Bath Rugby: 1 Jacob Yates (debut), 2 Jasper Spandler, 3 Kieran Verden, 4 Quinn Roux, 5 Ross Molony, 6 Ewan Richards (c), 7 George Timmins, 8 Arthur Green, 9 Tom Carr-Smith, 10 Ciaran Donoghue, 11 Will Muir, 12 Jack Harrison, 13 Charlie Griffin, 14 Tyler Offiah, 15 Jack Woods

Replacements: 16 Max Pearce, 17 Claudius Wheeler, 18 Marcos Camerlinckx, 19 Connor Treacey, 20 Jaco Coetzee, 21 Ieuan Davies, 22 Will Roue, 23 Austin Emens



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2026:11:13:12:06:16 by theredseat.

Tlacey90
Tlacey90
13/11/2026 12:04
Similar to last week with Yates in for Emmanuel who got injured at Chiefs in first half and Richards moving to 6. Return for Muir and Roux.
Bath Rugby: 1 Jacob Yates (debut), 2 Jasper Spandler, 3 Kieran Verden, 4 Quinn Roux, 5 Ross Molony, 6 Ewan Richards (c), 7 George Timmins, 8 Arthur Green, 9 Tom Carr-Smith, 10 Ciaran Donoghue, 11 Will Muir, 12 Jack Harrison, 13 Charlie Griffin, 14 Tyler Offiah, 15 Jack Woods

Replacements: 16 Max Pearce, 17 Claudius Wheeler, 18 Marcos Camerlinckx, 19 Connor Treacey, 20 Jaco Coetzee, 21 Ieuan Davies, 22 Will Roue, 23 Austin Emens

Gloucester have some experience at half back and Joyce in 2nd row and recognise some of the back row.
15 | Josh Hathaway (#2001), 14 | Ben Redshaw (#2065) 13 | Josiah Edwards-Giraud (#2049) 12 | Max Knight (#2026) 11 | Junior Denny (#2072) 10 | Ross Byrne (#2045) 09 | Mikey Austin (#2040) 1 | Harrison Bellamy (#2022) 2 | Kealan Freeman-Price (#2059) 3 | Eliot Salt (DEBUT) 4 | Joe Joyce (#2071) 5 | Jack Mann (#2063) 6 | Harry Taylor (C) (#1991) 7 | James Venter (#2046) 8 | Deian Gwynne (#2031)

Replacements

16 | George Knowles (#2034) 17 | Joe Cowell (LOAN / DEBUT) 18 | Harry Wright (#2052) 19 | Jack Gilbert (#2037) 20 | Caio James (#2025) 21 | Luca Woodyatt (DEBUT) 22 | Zac Jones (DEBUT) 23 | Krystof Wood (DEBUT)

opti
Optimist
13/11/2026 12:05
Glos look a wee bit rawer than us - not that I know their squad desperately well ... ?

theredseat
theredseat
13/11/2026 12:06
JC23 wearing 20. Feels weird. Don't like it.

MESSAGES->author
shipwrecked
13/11/2026 12:30
Jack Harrison is very strong in defense. George Timmins second game in a row, won a lot of line out ball last game.
Jack Woods fully deserves his place in a strong back line he is only 5 ft 10 in and 88 kg but is an elusive and powerful runner. Muir and Offiah on the wings might indicate an aerial approach. That's a strong bench as well. A great mix of a young front row with experienced locks. I suspect it will be too strong for Gloucester.

https://i.ibb.co/YTDNDCdd/Tyler-Offiah-185.jpg

Tyler Offiah

Opinion is based on assumptions, whereas fact is based on observation or research.

DorsetBoy
Dorset Boy
13/11/2026 12:35
Where has Jacob Yates come from?

tigersimon
tigersimon
13/11/2026 12:41
Quote:
Dorset Boy
Where has Jacob Yates come from?

[www.bathrugby.com]

MESSAGES->author
shipwrecked
13/11/2026 12:44
Quote:
Dorset Boy
Where has Jacob Yates come from?

Loose head prop from Bath Uni (final year.) regular starter in the double winning season last year.

https://i.ibb.co/YTDNDCdd/Tyler-Offiah-185.jpg

Tyler Offiah

Opinion is based on assumptions, whereas fact is based on observation or research.

Shadders
Shadders
13/11/2026 12:54
Both front rows look kind of 3/4th choice. Our back row is stronger. I recognise most of their backs, that should be a better match. Home advantage, stronger pack.... we should win by 15 at least.

And great to see Horse back! Let's hope he comes through unscathed.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2026:11:13:12:55:45 by Shadders.

theredseat
theredseat
13/11/2026 12:59
Quote:
Shadders
Both front rows look kind of 3/4th choice. Our back row is stronger. I recognise most of their backs, that should be a better match. Home advantage, stronger pack.... we should win by 15 at least.
And great to see Horse back! Let's hope he comes through unscathed.

Not sure there's loads in it for the back rows. Venter is a really solid, experienced player that gets through loads of work and Gwynne is going to earn plenty of Welsh caps in the next few years - wouldn't bet against him earning them as captain at some point either.

Charlieboa1
Charlieboa1
13/11/2026 17:34
I recognise quite a few in that glos squad and i am no glos officiado so feel like they have gone v mix and match as well.

Agree that home advantage will hopefully see us get the win.

BathOtter
BathOtter
13/11/2026 20:05
Anyone know if it is on YouTube again, a la the Chiefs game?

Charlieboa1
Charlieboa1
13/11/2026 20:22
Quote:
BathOtter
Anyone know if it is on YouTube again, a la the Chiefs game?

Yep, it is. Enjoy!

BathOtter
BathOtter
14/11/2026 09:05
Excellent news - thank you! Fingers crossed for some Bath myopia on the commentary this time around...

Susanne
Susanne
14/11/2026 15:22
What does it mean when you hear a Bath player call "eagle" during a play?

MESSAGES->author
Toast and Marmite
14/11/2026 15:47
Even allowing for the callow nature of the team, simply far too indisciplined allied to butchering numerous chances.

’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”

MESSAGES->author
hasta
14/11/2026 15:53
Quote:
Susanne
What does it mean when you hear a Bath player call "eagle" during a play?

Mostly it means a box kick is coming.

What an annoying game.

DorsetBoy
Dorset Boy
14/11/2026 16:05
not sure how Bath contrived to lose that when utter dominant in the second half.
Well apart from Gloucester being able to make repeated turnovers deep in their own 22.

Shadders
Shadders
14/11/2026 17:23
Disappointingly managed to make Ross Byrne look half decent in the first half. Hope Jaco is OK, he had a great game.

MESSAGES->author
hasta
14/11/2026 17:33
Quote:
Dorset Boy
not sure how Bath contrived to lose that when utter dominant in the second half.
Well apart from Gloucester being able to make repeated turnovers deep in their own 22.

This inability to adapt was infuriating though.

Also Ciaran needs to seriously work on his goal kicking.

dr.bath1865
dr.bath1865
14/11/2026 18:14
Shame, but fair play to Glos. Kinda seems they are where we were a few seasons ago, where the players are all completely on the same page and they’re loving getting wins and surprising a few people. I actually enjoyed the game… I’d have hated it if it was PREM.

Felt like Wales NZ in the last quarter. We threw a lot at them, likely without quite enough creativity or thought, but they managed to hold us out and held on. Fair play. Great to see Roux, Muir and Coetzee back. The Argie tighthead seems great.

Bath Hammer
Bath Hammer
14/11/2026 18:15
Bath were utterly infuriating going back to how they have been throughout the season so far. I thought they had improved a great deal in the last match but we have reverted again to indiscipline, errors and poor decision-making constantly keeping the ball within the pack when attacking the line which so often fails. Gloucester by contrast took all their opportunities and unlike us spinned the ball wide to score their tries. tThis seems to be our approach whoever we have in our team and we need to be far more flexible if we are too progress this season. Even so we could’ve won if O’Donoghue had kicks his goals.

Rowancroft73
Rowancroft73
14/11/2026 20:58
JvG was often maligned at Munster for his limited attacking game plan. This has, for sometime, been evident in Bath’s play. Almost as though JvG is an advocate of Rassie’s approach. With such talent in the outside backs i can only imagine the frustration from them with the fact that ‘creativity’ doesnt seem to be his mantra

Charlieboa1
Charlieboa1
14/11/2026 21:58
Feels like we have got the u18s, uni, prem cup and senior playing squads v aligned in playing style which is good.

Problem is that style now seems a bit limited and dated.

Breakdown is a recurring issue. Even pepper who arrived as an absolute jackal king has gone off the boil.

Replacement front row did well and jaco was a handful.

Good to see horse back.

Tbf to donoghue he is a v good , dilligent goalkicker who had an off day imho.

MESSAGES->author
CoochieCoo
14/11/2026 22:08
Exactly Charlie Ciaran was very good at Exeter but today he was not anywhere near his best.

MESSAGES->author
exbathballboy
14/11/2026 23:18
Quote:
Rowancroft73
JvG was often maligned at Munster for his limited attacking game plan. This has, for sometime, been evident in Bath’s play. Almost as though JvG is an advocate of Rassie’s approach. With such talent in the outside backs i can only imagine the frustration from them with the fact that ‘creativity’ doesnt seem to be his mantra

It is a worry. Today's team though was managed by Lilley, who is doing a good job with the pathway system.

Defense work was a bit shocking.
What happened to the offloading game from last week?
Two recent defeats to Gloucester hurts.

Bath Hammer
Bath Hammer
14/11/2026 23:48
We were able to succeed with this method with powerful forwards who were supplemented by the bomb squad, including one of the best in the world, who got us over the line on numerous occasions. However, he is persisting with that method in quite different circumstances & refusing to change, meaning we are continually throwing away opportunities to score. It is becoming frustrating, boring & self destructive. There were plenty of other things wrong but despite. not playing at all well & missing loads of goal kicks we could still have won today if we had attacked the line as Gloucester did & used our backs.. I don’t want to keep watching this. Its maddening & we’re not going to reach the top 4 playing like that. It was galling to read that JvG is happy with how things are. How many of us agree with him.

MESSAGES->author
exbathballboy
15/11/2026 05:02
I really hope when the Gallagher Premiership returns, there will be a shift in approach. All the games up until the Sale match were hard to watch. And they were Munster like.

But I am hoping our new attack coach can settle in a bit more now. Players like Ojomoh play great attacking rugby as he did for England today. Spencer being more match fit. And keep giving young players like Green, Jeanes, Tepu a chance, we can turn this around.

Bath Hammer
Bath Hammer
15/11/2026 06:59
We’ve always been able to score impressive tries from open play but yesterday we failed with about 3 of those from poor execution which was another frustration, Carr-Smith was involved a couple of times. I was talking about when are forwards are in control & always expecting a rolling maul try to be successful . Sometimes they are so it is a difficult judgement call but we certainly don’t get that right. We fail a gain & again.

Barfboy
Barfboy
15/11/2026 08:30
Am I right in thinking both Jaco and Green went off injured?

Great to see Horse and Roux back. Both sorely missed.

dcsh
dcsh
15/11/2026 08:47
Quote:
Barfboy
Am I right in thinking both Jaco and Green went off injured?
Great to see Horse and Roux back. Both sorely missed.
Yes, both Green and Jaco were down for a long time before going off, it looked like Green was cut and Jaco knocked out from in the ground.

Barfboy
Barfboy
15/11/2026 10:51
Rubbish but not musculoskeletal at least!

Old Bath Tub
Old Bath Tub
15/11/2026 12:25
Watched live yesterday and just watched on YT just to try and see why our defense went missing and why Gloucester were sharper, was it Ross Byrne and a combination of a much better game plan.?

When the scores leveled I thought we would keep them out . (Sm128)

Bristol next ! (Sm136)

Adopted Player 2018/19 Ross Batty
Adopted Player 2019/20 Jack Davies
Adopted Player 2020/21 Cam Redpath
Adopted Player 2021/22 Darren Atkins
Adopted Player 2022/23 Gabriel Hamer-Webb
Adopted Player 2023/24 Tom Carr-Smith
Adopted Player 2024/25 Max Ojomoh

"AN OUNCE OF ACTION IS WORTH A TON OF THEORY"
FRIEDRICH ENGELS

Bath Hammer
Bath Hammer
15/11/2026 12:32
One reason contributing to our loss was that O’Donohue had a poor kicking game whereas he apparently had an excellent match last week. F/H doesn’t seem a natural fit for him.

Bath Supporter Jack
Bath Supporter Jack
15/11/2026 13:00
Just rewatched the game.

TCS pass is not fast enough, one step and a looping pass.

Discipline poor, lots of penalties conceded to jackaling at critical moments.

Donoghue needs to practice his kicking to right hand touchline which was very, very poor.

At 31 - 31 should/could have pushed on and won.

Our squad are just not as good as we think they are and not as energised as the Gloucester squad were.

Need a complete rethink of the Club's approach/attitude

opti
Optimist
15/11/2026 13:59
Is this notion that we have a very fixed gameplan/pattern that is inculcated across every player and permutation starting to look a bit of a myth? Feels like we have played differently in every single game this season, and seemingly taking the worst, rather than the best bits from the orevious weekend’s performance. It might partly be the ridiculously structured season with no one competition having any real flow.

Bath Hammer
Bath Hammer
15/11/2026 14:11
Yes, maybe, but I don’t think it’s down to the structure of the season. That was not a problem in our two really good years. We are now back looking for excuses. I thought Gloucester deserved to win & look to have overtaken us incredibly quickly!

MESSAGES->author
The Bear
15/11/2026 14:38
Quote:
Bath Hammer
I thought Gloucester deserved to win & look to have overtaken us incredibly quickly!

I think it just highlights the importance of the mental aspect of the game. Gloucester haven't found some skeleton key tactic this season. They've made some canny signings and belief is xoursing through the squad.

The current Bath team seem to have a bit of crisis of confidence. Still a quality team but we dont seem to have the belief that we can hold teams out or that we can overcome them by sticking to the plan. We're looking for answers and trying things that arent working.

Bath Supporter Jack
Bath Supporter Jack
15/11/2026 16:04
I think we need to go back to basics

Better discipline, the penalties are killing our momentum and pressure on the opposition. Better to not go that extra yard and remain connected with your own players.

More precision, better passing (I thought the passing was poor against Gloucester)

Don't force it....on a couple of occasions we made a pass that was not there to be made, either forward or player getting the ball was already well covered. Don't make the near impossible pass, be patient and work another phase.

Much faster reactions and speed of thought.

Silly thing to say but don't be so easy to score tries against.......

MESSAGES->author
OutsideBath
15/11/2026 16:09
Can’t comment on this match, but JvG has always said he wants us to be difficult to beat. That’s certainly not been the case this season.

opti
Optimist
15/11/2026 16:23
From the basketball game against Saints to the mind-numbing head-banging of the Glos game I just have no clear sense of what we’re about this year.

Goto Page: 123Next
Current Page: of 3
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net