I hope BMW will appeal because this looks like most stupid verdict of the year - which is quite an achievement.

Yeah, hope so too.

I'm amazed by the ability of FIA to invent new rules and penalties. SInce when there is a 3 place demotion? Wasn't it either 5 place loss of the best quali times removed?

Makes no sense, especially after all the complains about the pitlane entry and exit. In fact Nick had no place to go.

The penalty should go to Tilke, who designed the circuit.


BMW Sauber Latest News HERE!

I am so angry.

There was NOTHING he could do!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2008:09:27:18:10:49 by Scarletkatz.

Idiots

So you prefer +5 penalty to +3? LOL

Quote:

J-Raid
Yeah, hope so too.
I'm amazed by the ability of FIA to invent new rules and penalties. SInce when there is a 3 place demotion? Wasn't it either 5 place loss of the best quali times removed?

Sorry, no appeal here.

Heidfeld's reaction at http://www.f1network.net/main/s491/st134052.htm

Quote:

Sorry, no appeal here

Another reason not to like FIA proceedings.

Wait, it says "practice sessions", not quali or race (which probably would be called in another way). Or does the word practice include quali?


BMW Sauber Latest News HERE!

to be honest i think most honda fans would agree with you who invents a circuit with the entrance and exit to the pits on the racing line nick had no where to go unless hes david blaine

Heidfeld's Q&A at http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/70947


BMW Sauber Latest News HERE!

That was a stupid penalty. Where the .... should he go? if the entry to the pits is in the racing line, then where is drivers who is driving into the pits supposed to go!?


stupid..


2006 and 2007 Prediction Champion

Quote:

J-Raid
The penalty should go to Tilke, who designed the circuit.

this is also what I'm thinking

Quote:

J-Raid
The penalty should go to Tilke, who designed the circuit.

actually(surprise, surprise) he didn't

it was Kellogg Brown & Root

I can't see how Heidfeld can be penalized either. Even if he had held the car tight to the inside of the circuit, Barrichello's line would have still been compromised.

As for the rule that was quoted, the interesting part is that it should have been applied to Trulli's infraction for driving against traffic on Friday, rahter than the fine which was imposed.

"Speed has never killed anyone, suddenly becoming stationary... That's what gets you."-Jeremy Clarkson

I hope Nick will gain those three position at the start. Good luck NICK!!!

seems fia wants to look impartial so it slaps penalties left, right and centre... (then again justice is blind, isn't she?)

regards tt

After watching the video I would say the penalty was right. Nick had enough time on the straight before the last corner to see Honda in his mirrors.

[www.wrzuta.pl]

Of course it doesn't change the fact, that the pit entry should be redesigned.

Three more cars to pass is what it boils down to being.
At this stage lady luck will take over. Three places back may or may not work for him. If there is a first turn mess up he may avoid it. If it happens further back, he's could be toast.
If it rains, who's to say.
Does the three grid penalty allow him the privilege of changing his fuel load ?
At any rate its a pi$$ off that tends to deflate ones moral, but knowing Nick's consistency he'll bring her home. The big question, will it be in the points ?

Fingers crossed, Sessions