Username
Password
St. Johnstone (1) v. Airdrie (1), 23/10/04
By Gordon Thomson October 24 2004
Airdrie threw away two points against a hapless St. Johnstone side that once again failed to live up to their ‘pre-season favourite’ tag. On paper it looked like Owen Coyle had save a point, but given Airdrie’s superiority, the majority of fans left rueing earlier missed chances and a bizarre sub…

Unsurprisingly Airdrie stuck with the same starting eleven that took care of Partick seven days earlier, therefore the inspirational Alan Gow was left on the bench beside Varielle, Roberts and McManus. St. Johnstone showed a few changes from earlier in the season. In came on-loan Rangers goalie Alan McGregor, Forsyth, Alan Mahood, Sean Webb, Peter MacDonald, Chris Hay and Mark Baxter – the kid who scored their fortunate equaliser in the cup-tie almost two years ago. Talking of that cup-tie, the homer of a ref in that replay, Mike Ritchie, was the man in the middle today too. Names such as Paul Bernard, Ian Maxwell, David Hannah and Michael Moore were amongst the missing names.

AIRDRIE UTD

McGeown
Docherty, Christie, McGowan, Lovering
Barkey, M.Wilson, Hardie, McLaren
McKeown, Coyle,

St. Johnstone

McGregor
Tait, Rutkiewicz, Webb, Forsyth
Baxter, Mahood, Sheerin
MacDonald, Hay, Hardy

Check out Bob Dalzell's photo gallery of the game. Remember his photos are copyright controlled.

Let’s just say that the one point we collected here was another case of under achievement on the part of the Airdrieonians. Though he might not say it publically, surely Sandy Stewart, and Jim Ballantyne, will know that yet again they could, and should, have collected more points from this game than they actually did. The Falkirk thrashing apart, hopefully to be rectified next week, there has been nothing, and I mean nothing, in this league that should scare Airdrie. Today against St. Johnstone we looked a much better side all round, despite a few deficiencies of our own, but toiled to make the most telling contribution: GOALS. There were of course a few near chances, but probably just not enough in the areas that counted.

From the word go, Airdrie pounded on a poor St. Johnstone pack. Marvyn Wilson is now playing the game at an SPL tempo and he’s been aided in his midfield partnership by an equally tough team-mate in Martin Hardie. Last season Marv didn’t seem to be at his best with either Docherty or Dunn beside him but he and Hardie are a match for any midfield at the moment. St. Johnstone simply couldn’t cope with them despite having Mahood and Sheerin in there. Apart from some miscued passes from Marv, the wee man was again superb for us. The problem for Airdrie on this occasion was poor finishing and possibly a lack of ambition in the last third of the pitch.

Kevin Barkey had the best of the first half chances with an effort he lifted over the goalie, only to be distraught at the sight of the man with the name that reads like an optician’s eye-chart clearing the goal-bound effort off the line. Early in the second half Stephen McKeown charged down a defender, hussled the advancing keeper who’d strayed outside his box, then proceeded to rush the effort as he had a clear path to goal, albeit from a difficult angle, and sliced his effort across the six-yard box. If he was trying to square to Coyle he was miles out. Besides, that would be making excuses for him. Airdrie had another great chance when Coyle, with his only decent contribution in the first 89 minutes, played in McLaren down the left with a beautiful through ball. McLaren, by this time breathing through his butt, was clear of the defence but at a favourable angle the maverick talent managed to fluff his shot high and wide of the goal when most Airdrie fans knew he’d score. D’oh!

St. Johnstone’s goal was, to be kind, undeserved. With the substition of McConalogue for Hay only a minute old, McConalogue used his pace (something the Saints had previously lacked) to make space down the left. The cross into the Airdrie penalty area was met by our slumbering giant, Kevin Christie, who managed to divert the harmless cross beyond Mark McGeown.

Thankfully the previously infuriating Owen Coyle was there to ‘save the day’. Paul Lovering went the extra yard, and not for the first time either, to close down a counter-attack, and the loose ball fell to late substitute Gow, who fed Marv in the midfield. Marv’s ball into Coyle’s feet, in the ‘D’, let Coyle side-step Rutkiewicz and right-footed, he placed the ball out of McGregor’s reach for a last minute winner.

On paper, it may look like a point saved, but for anyone at the match, the game’s outcome hinged on a bizarre subsitution. About ten minutes into the second half McKeown had picked up a leg knock. By then, the game was already calling for the mercurial talents of Alan Gow to light us up. Till then we’d been disappointing in the last quarter. Instead of Gow though, the crowd almost to a man gasped in near disbelief at the sight of Mark Roberts coming on. Needless to say that decision didn’t look any better in hindsight. When Gow did eventually come on, equally bizarrely for Hardie, hd did look quite superb. With McGowan going off injured earlier using up McManus, it also robbed us of the chance of replacing the ineffective Barkey with Varielle. Maybe it wouldn’t have been enough, but in fairness, it was what the crowd wanted to see. Hopefully McGowan will recover in time for the Falkirk game, his pace will be invaluable against Duffy, and Gow will be deemed fit to start.

McGeown Has his dodgy moments but overall ok. 6/10
Docherty The usual mix of near brilliant and near useless. Showed some great pace at times and some tough tackling. Positionally suspect though in patches. 6/10
Christie Single handedly turning Scotsport First into ‘car-crash TV’. I may be being hard on him, but he seems to be very calamity prone at times, especially against quick players. On top of the own goal he seemed to give the ball away a lot. 4/10
McGowan Still striving for top form but looked pacy and aggressive till he picked up a knock mid-way through the second half. Worryingly he was caught in possession and had a few misplaced passes.. 6/10
Lovering Provided a lot of quality on the left, and displayed the kind of commitment that should be the standard throughout the side. 7/10
Barkey Very disappointing. Unlucky not to score, but too often looks to go backward when in possession. Doesn’t have the pace to take a man on but does provide quality delivery, but just not often enough today. 5/10
M. Wilson Another all action display. Controlled the midfield. Would be an SPL quality player if only he could pass better. At least six time he gave the ball away, but summed up his attitude by aggressively winning the ball back when humanly possible. 8/10
Hardie Helped Marv dominate the midfield. Surely a goal isn’t going to take much longer to arrive?. 7/10
McLaren Made a lot of runs through the middle but couldn’t get the right service. Fluffed a great chance midway through the second half but was looking knackered by that point. 7/10
Coyle 89 minutes of near mediocrity then, BANG, the equaliser. His build up play at times verged on atrocious, putting additional strain on the defence, but he still pops in the goals like a youngster. Maybe there should be an unwritten rule that no-one passes to Coyle outside the penalty box? You just can’t argue with a living legend though, can you? That was his sixth league goal so far, and counting. 5/10
McKeown You can’t argue with his work-rate or commitment, but he isn’t making the runs he should be. He’s holding the ball up well and his all-round play is good, but he’s not threatening the goal. I wouldn’t be too critical of his glaring miss considering the chance was all down to his own hard graft but with Gow on the horizon he may need to work his way back from the bench. 6/10
s. Roberts ( for McKeown after about 55 mins) Not a great display n/a
s. McManus (for McGowan after about 70mins) Pretty much like-for-like. n/a
s. Gow (for Hardie with about 15 mins left – Roberts going into midfield) Didn’t get long enough to impose himself fully, but you could immediately see the difference in quality he brings to the team. n/a

Bookmark or share this story with:

£25 free bet with Paddy Power