By Gordon Thomson
October 28 2003
Airdrie had won the Challenge Cup three times out of three but thanks in no small part to a prematch injury crisis and one vital cog of our defence missing thanks to that wee nugget from Stenhousemuir we were going in a little less confident than we would have hoped.
In the run up to the game it was reported that all our starting forwards plus Docherty were fitness doubts. Add to that Scott Wilson who had to come out of last weeks game early and it adds up to a less than ideal preparation for any game, never mind a cup final. Somehow Ian Constable managed to get a full strength team, minus Neil McGowan, on the pitch though some were visibly fitter than others and the cracks would re-appear to our cost later. Airdrie had to change from the normal 343 formation to cope with Caley's 433, Airdrie matching them by putting Docherty in midfield. AIRDRIE UTD
Airdrie started the game slowly taking a good ten minutes to change to the above formation to cope with Caley's three pronged attack. The vital battle was on the left of our defence where Woosh Wilson was in direct opposition to Caley's most likely, Barry Wilson. Caley's only dangerous moves all game came down that flank. Otherwise Airdrie battled them all over the park as best as could be hoped. McManus, Stewart and Scott Wilson all looked solid early on and Doc, Marv and Dunn eventually got to grips with the midfield after a torrid opening twenty minutes. Up front though Gow, Vareille and Roberts were never going to get it easy against such a good defence. In our years in Division One guys like Bobby Mann, Stuart McCafferty, Ross Tokely and Stuart Golabek were always solid defenders who all looked capable of playing in the SPL and today was again no exception with McCafferty and Tokely outstanding for them. Mann's passing out of defence too was a major feature for them. Their one weakness though was their lack of mobility. We pumped a few high balls in that were never going to break them down but when we played to Roberts' feet his clever lay offs were helping Gow and Vareille to turn them but to no avail.
Caley dominated early on but really only had a few dangerous corners that McGeown kind of flapped at, and despite us being superior for the last half hour of the first half we really only had on clear cut chance when Varielle ghosted behind Mann, but his attempt to lift the ball over Mark Brown frustratingly clipped the crossbar. Dunn was increasingly dominating things in the first half and was outstanding in the midfield.
Second half Airdrie kept plugging away but the fitness concerns were becoming more apparent. Jerome didn't look right and Roberts was toiling after taking an absolute battering in the first half but it was Docherty who was first to go off with Singbo coming on in midfield. Let me point out that though I'm not keen on Docherty the midfielder I think he's a decent defender so with McGowan missing it was double jeopardy as our only cover for the defence was now gone. We were still chipping away at Caley well past the midway point of the half when the roof just about fell in. Scott Wilson went battling across the half way line when he got involved in a gritty couple of challenges with the Caley midfield and came limping back with his tail between his legs much to Sandy Stewart's dismay. The look on the gaffer's face said it all. With Scott Wilson off, Ronaldo on in midfield, Singbo had to play as a makeshift right back. With Woosh overrun on the left and now Singbo looking out of place on the right, our defence was really up against it. To make matters worse we were shooting ourselves in the foot. Marv Wilson had made a fantastic burst through the midfield, and with the Caley defence all at sea, we had all three strikers pealing off making all the right moves but Marv inexplicably dithered before passing straight to one of their relieved defenders. Marv then went on a mad spell of giving the ball away at least four times in a row culminating in losing possession for their first goal. Wilson galloping away down the right to cross for "plug" Bingham to head home. McManus in the middle of our defence didn't exactly read it too well and was easily beaten. Dosser came on for Vareille inside the last ten minutes but it was Caley who wrapped it up with seconds to go when sub. Hislop ran from deep, held off a brave challenge from Marv then rounded McManus to score. In fairness to McManus I think he tweaked a muscle soon after Scott Wilson went off but he played on rather than leave us with ten men, those being the breaks when you have such a small squad.
| McGeown | Didn't have much to do. Looked suspect at some cross balls but had a fantastic save from Wilson | 6/10 |
| McManus | Had a good 77minutes but looked slow and leaden at both goals. I did see him pull up injured just before it but he battled on. | 6/10 |
| Stewart | Outstanding, but struggles to keep his eye on the job when he has to make substitutions. | 7/10 |
| S. Wilson | Commanding till he went off injured | 7/10 |
| W.Wilson | Like the Clyde game he had to cope with the opposition's best forward and he was over run. | 6/10 |
| Marvyn Wilson | Battled away gamely but had a spell where his distribution inadvertantly cost us the game. Such a pity because he has the fitness to play for another six or seven seasons yet. His thrusting runs from midfield really help drive us on late in games but too often the moves collapse due to misplaced passes. | 7/10 |
| Docherty | A fitness doubt and it caught up with him. Was having a reasonable game in midfield. We could really have done with him in defence in the last quarter of an hour and we'd maybe have been celebrating. | 7/10 |
| Dunn | Took ten minutes to settle down but when he did he was outstanding. Another display of box to box midfield trickery. | 8/10 |
| Roberts | Was kicked up and down the park like a ragdoll. Was never going to beat Mann and McCafferty in the air but linked well with the other strikers when the ball was on the deck. | 7/10 |
| Vareille | He was a bit out of touch with his fitness in question but did reasonably well, especially his near miss in the first half. | 6/10 |
| Gow | Couldn't beat Tokely as easily as the second division defenders but still battled hard all afternoon. | 8/10 |
| s. Singbo (c.60mins for Docherty) | Was just settling into the midfield when he was sent to right back. Struggled then on but didn't let us down. | n/a |
| McKeown(c80mins for Varielle) | Didn't get much of a chance. | n/a |
| Ronald(c75mins for Scott Wilson) | Hardly involved | n/a |
All in all a disappointing ending to a good day. ICT were a decent side who had the first quarter of an hour before we dominated them. Injuries to key defenders and McGowan's absence cost us the game and that's just tough cheddar on us. Sandy Stewart set out a decent side who competed well and each man gave 100%. With the A90 a sea of red and white it was still a day to be proud of. A year odd ago we had nothing. Today we lost a cup final. Thank you to the Ballantyne and Spiers families. Thank you Sandy Stewart and the players for giving their all. Thank you to all the Airdrie fans who made it such a good day out. And one last thing.... ROLL ON SATURDAY!!!!
